• Home Page
    • 12step
  • Reading Room
    • client care
    • orders
    • Sample Book
  • Rebellious Radio
    • Speaking/Events/Workshops
  • Secular Recovery Meetings and Links
  • Blog
  • Merch & Gift Store
  • 30Things
    • 30 THINGS: Practical Advice for Living Well by William Schaberg
Rebellion Dogs Publishing

Rebellion Dogs Publishing

  • Home Page
    • 12step
  • Reading Room
    • client care
    • orders
    • Sample Book
  • Rebellious Radio
    • Speaking/Events/Workshops
  • Secular Recovery Meetings and Links
  • Blog
  • Merch & Gift Store
  • 30Things
    • 30 THINGS: Practical Advice for Living Well by William Schaberg
Back to all posts

Modernity and Fundamentalism dance to new facts about AA from the Great Britain 2020 Membership Survey 

With or Without God: the latest Alcoholics Anonymous Membership Survey from Great Britain identifies how many members are religious vs. secular. 

Episode 69 of Rebellion Dogs Radio  looks at our more enlightened understanding of AA members, at least a significant sample size surveyed this decade. The findings from the Great Britain 2020 AA Membership Survey + English Speaking Central Europe meetings have shared their experience and their understanding of how AA works for them. We look, more broadly, not only at this modernism movement that includes measurable assessment of AA members and AA life today, but we look at how progress is happening in AA. We look at AA maturity in the context of fundamentalism AND modernity, in AA. It is worth viewing both sides: what are the payoffs for those who embrace a strict orthodoxy and why and what do we need to change to better reach more of those who come to us with alcohol or other substance use disorder.

Download or read a PDF transcript of Episode 69 of Rebellion Dogs Radio with links

Every five years the Great Britain General Service Conferences surveys members to:

  • carry the message to professionals, and 
  • help inform the General Service Conference for future decision making.

In 2020 members in Great Britain and English speaking Europe were asked: "Do you believe in a higher power?"

Those who answered "yes" were asked: "Is your higher power religious or secular?"

  • 35% of members hold a religious belief about higher power.
  • 65% of members hold a secular belief about higher power.

From there we ask how this might "inform the General Service Conference for future decision making," and how AA is doing overall in the first two decades of Century 21 in balancing the need to modernize AA and the resistance to change felt by fundamentalist AAs.

 

Our musical feature (Pictured Above) is a Toronto/NYC trio called ON, with their new song "Underdog." 

Here are some links to items quoted and discussed..

A Newcomer Ask - second most read leaflet/pamphlet in all of AA originating in Great Britain

https://www.alcoholics-anonymous.org.uk/Members/2020-Survey 

https://www.alcoholics-anonymous.org.uk/Professionals/Interesting-Statistics 

The 2020 Great Britain Membership survey

YouGov 2020 survey of religiosity in Britain

 Ernie Kurtz seven step program for research and reporting

 Search back issues for group and member estimates (generally in Summer Issue each year of Box 459) 

World Health Organization facts about alcohol

148 country comparison of religious adherence

American belief in God through the years

New York State Bill ensuring the right to irreligious drug/alcohol treatment

The most recent USA/Canada membership survey

Listen to "Overhaul?" from the December 2009 AA Grapevine

CONCEPT V Throughout our world service structure, a traditional “Right of Appeal” ought to prevail, thus assuring us that minority opinion will be heard and that petitions for the redress of personal grievances will be carefully considered. p. 207 

Generous Orthodoxy and AA with Jackie B from Varieties of Secular Experiences 2021

Religious Fundamentalism Modulates Neural Responses to Error-Related Words: The Role of Motivation Toward Closure 

Fanaticism is a disease like alcoholism (Psychology Today)

https://www.britannica.com/topic/fundamentalism 

AA Efficacy from 1955 Bill Wilson, Alcoholics Anonymous, Fourth Edition, p. XX 

Updated language in Twelve Steps and Twelve Traditions (p. 66, and p. 117)

A longitudinal study of the comparative efficacy of Women for Sobriety LifeRing, SMART, 12-step groups for those with Alcohol Use Disorder (AUD) -  Sara E Zemore et al 

Rebellion Dogs favorite reading:

David Best, (2019) Pathways to Recovery and Desistance: the role of the social contagion of hope, Bristol, Policy Press 

Marya Hornbacher (2011) Waiting: A Nonbeliever's Higher Power

William Schaberg (2019) Writing the Big Book: The Creation of AA

 Bill Wilson's three years on know-how, Alcoholics Anonymous, p. 85 

Fundamentalism is faith based in fear from The Daily Dish

0:00/???
  1. Rebellion Dogs Radio Episode 69 Sept 2022 Modernity and Fundamentalism in 12 Step Culture today
Subscribe with iTunes RSS feed Download

09/02/2022

  • Leave a comment
  • Share
    Modernity and Fundamentalism dance to new facts about AA from the Great Britain 2020 Membership Survey

    Share link

Leave a comment



Beyond Belief (book)

Merch (T-shirts, mugs, gifts and fun stuff)

Sample Book

Speaking/Events/Workshops

Orders (bulk for treatment centers), booksellers, groups

Galleries

Policy 

 

 

Some images ©

  • Log out

notes
0:00/???
  1. 1
    Audio only Joe C @ Symposium on AA History 47:58
    Audio only Joe C @ Symposium on AA History

    Share link

    0:00/47:58
  2. 2
    Bob k and AA's history of story telling on Rebellion Dogs Radio # 20 1:06:37
    Bob k and AA's history of story telling on Rebellion Dogs Radio # 20

    Share link

    0:00/1:06:37
  3. 3
    A House is on Fire 3:33
    A House is on Fire

    Share link

    0:00/3:33
  4. 4
    "Growing Along Spiritual Lines" with Joe C (atheist) and Joe R (priest) 42:46
    "Growing Along Spiritual Lines" with Joe C (atheist) and Joe R (priest)

    Share link

    Free
    0:00/42:46
  5. 5
    Debate Over Special Purpose Groups 58:26
    Debate Over Special Purpose Groups

    Share link

    0:00/58:26
  6. 6
    Tracy Chabala Episode 37 Rebellion Dogs Radio 1:05:16
    Tracy Chabala Episode 37 Rebellion Dogs Radio

    Share link

    0:00/1:05:16
  7. 7
    Barry Leach on Tradition Three from World Conference 1985 25:15
    Barry Leach on Tradition Three from World Conference 1985

    Share link

    0:00/25:15
  8. 8
    Austin TX, WAAFTIAAC 58:26
    Austin TX, WAAFTIAAC
    by Rebellion Dogs Radio #25

    Share link

    Free
    0:00/58:26
  9. 9
    Rebellion_Dogs_27_November2016 57:55
    Rebellion_Dogs_27_November2016

    Share link

    0:00/57:55
  10. 10
    Episode 19 A Principle of Recovery & Sober but never Clean 54:42
    Episode 19 A Principle of Recovery & Sober but never Clean

    Share link

    0:00/54:42
  11. 11
    Joe C speaks in Berlin August 2021 18:17
    Joe C speaks in Berlin August 2021

    Share link

    Info
    0:00/18:17
  12. 12
    Women in Recovery with Trysh Travis 1:10:19
    Women in Recovery with Trysh Travis

    Share link

    Free
    0:00/1:10:19
  13. 13
    ORC ontario regional AA conference 2023 Craig F (Banquet) 53:56
    ORC ontario regional AA conference 2023 Craig F (Banquet)

    Share link

    0:00/53:56
  14. 14
    49 years sober Joe C at Toronto Beyond Belief Nov 27 2025 15:41
    49 years sober Joe C at Toronto Beyond Belief Nov 27 2025

    Share link

    Info
    Free
    0:00/15:41
  15. 15
    Author Joe C, AA Talk Toronto 2007 28:22
    Author Joe C, AA Talk Toronto 2007

    Share link

    0:00/28:22
  16. 16
    WeAgnosticsPanel 1990 Seatle AA WorldCovention 1:21:25
    WeAgnosticsPanel 1990 Seatle AA WorldCovention

    Share link

    0:00/1:21:25
  17. 17
    Overhaul? by Joe C., Grapevine December 2009 5:25
    Overhaul? by Joe C., Grapevine December 2009

    Share link

    0:00/5:25
  18. 18
    We Agnostics 1990 Seattle 1:21:25
    We Agnostics 1990 Seattle
    by Rebellion Dogs Publishing

    Share link

    Free
    0:00/1:21:25
  19. 19
    Mere Addiction Rebellion Dogs Radio 42 1:06:39
    Mere Addiction Rebellion Dogs Radio 42

    Share link

    0:00/1:06:39
  20. 20
    Dr. Joe Nowinski, The Science of the 12 Step fellowship and program 52:02
    Dr. Joe Nowinski, The Science of the 12 Step fellowship and program
    by Rebellion Dogs Radio

    Share link

    Free
    0:00/52:02
0:00/???